Feature

Unlocking TNE’s Potential

Transnational education continues to evolve—but success remains a matter of trust.
TNE’s growth is both a response to changing demographics and geopolitical realities and a tool to expand access, strengthen collaborative research, and solve complex problems that transcend national boundaries. Image: Shutterstock
 

Ceremonial bagpipes and tartans abound during special events at Heriot-Watt University Malaysia (HWUM), the southeast Asian branch campus of the 205-year-old Scottish university. But as it prepares to celebrate its 15th anniversary in 2027, HWUM’s green campus—Malaysia’s first—is far from a carbon copy of its counterpart in Edinburgh.

The university’s “journey in Malaysia has always been about more than bringing a high-quality British education to this part of the world,” says Professor Mushtak Al-Atabi, HWUM’s provost and CEO. “Our mission has evolved from providing access to international education to developing individuals who can navigate uncertainty, contribute to society, and help shape Malaysia’s future.”

The changing focus reflects the ongoing evolution of transnational education, or TNE. Once understood as branch campuses open beyond the host institution’s borders, TNE now encompasses a wide range of collaborative activities, from dual and joint degree programs to franchise agreements and partnerships funded by third-party investors. TNE’s growth is both a response to changing demographics and geopolitical realities and a tool to expand access, strengthen collaborative research, and solve complex problems that transcend national boundaries.

“We are at an interesting historical juncture. The international landscape is favorable for TNE.” —Fabrizio Trifiró

“We are at an interesting historical juncture,” says Fabrizio Trifiró, associate pro vice chancellor for educational partnerships at Bath Spa University, which operates a branch campus in the United Arab Emirates and has partnerships with universities in Ukraine and elsewhere. As large receiving countries are limiting inbound students and more international students are exploring regional options, “the international landscape is favorable for TNE,” says Trifiró, who spent more than 15 years involved in quality assurance and regulation of international education in the UK and with the International Network for Quality Assurance Agencies in Higher Education. 

Unpacking TNE

Sometimes called “cross-border education,” TNE is broadly defined as any higher education setting where learners are in a different country than the home institution. “Across the globe, we’re seeing institutions that want to maintain global relevance,” says Janet B. Ilieva, founder and director of Education Insight, a research group focused on TNE. “The only way to do that is to be where students are.”

TNE takes on many forms, including:

International branch campuses are a satellite operation of a university in another country. Branch campuses remain the most familiar approach to TNE, in large part because host countries “see them as a sign of greater commitment from foreign providers,” according to Trifiró.

As of September 2026, there were 382 branch campuses worldwide, located in 85 countries and run by institutions in 40 countries, according to research from the Cross-Border Education Research Team (C-BERT). The United States leads the export pack, with 98 institutions operating branch campuses—but it is no longer alone. “That’s largely a historical artifact,” says Jason Lane, professor at the University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign and C-BERT co-founder and co-director. “A lot of activity has happened across the globe.”

“Across the globe, we’re seeing institutions that want to maintain global relevance. The only way to do that is to be where students are.” —Janet B. Ilieva

Accreditation issues make the branch campus model the easiest for U.S. colleges and universities to export. Examples span a wide range of institutional types and missions, including the Georgetown University School of Foreign Service in Qatar, the Georgia Institute of Technology’s campus in Metz, France, City University of Seattle’s four Canadian campuses, and the Tianjin Juilliard School in China. However, only the largest and best-resourced institutions typically have the capacity to sustain these models over the long-run, according to Trifiró.

Dual- and joint-degree programs represent collaboration among institutions in different countries. Joint degrees are generally more integrated programs between two universities that share responsibility for curriculum design, teaching, and quality assurance. One example is the University of Arizona’s microcampus network, which offers collaborative degrees while serving as a hub for cross-border research and other activities.

In some cases, an outside investor provides financial support, making it a three-party partnership, according to Ilieva. And some countries, including the Philippines, now require these collaborative models to help build domestic capacity; one example is a collaboration between the University of Liverpool and Bicol University to offer joint postgraduate programs in agricultural disciplines. “The advantage for western universities using this approach is that enrollments are managed by a trusted local partner who knows how to engage and reach local students,” helping reduce risk, Ilieva says.

Validation programs and franchise partnerships. In the former, local institutions design programming which is approved by the international university. In the latter, a university allows an institution overseas to deliver its academic programs locally while maintaining oversight. While U.S. accreditation limits U.S. institutions, these programs are the predominant models in other TNE-exporting countries, including the UK and Australia. The UK’s Open University Validation Partnerships, for example, oversees more than 400 programs for nearly 40 institutions serving 60,000 students worldwide. Validation and franchies models are attractive because they require fewer resources to launch and maintain than branch campuses, Trifiró says. The host institutions, meanwhile, gain credibility and capacity.

Articulation agreements are structured pathways between institutions allowing students to begin in one country and complete in another. Mirroring domestic 2+2 models in which students first receive an associate degree and then transfer to a four-year institution, articulation agreements are particularly valuable to institutions which want to increase the number of international students who (eventually) come to the home campus. The American University of Rome, for example, offers students the ability to start their studies in Rome and transfer to American University or Northern Arizona University—or to begin at Florida’s Broward College and complete their degree in Italy. These agreements also provide opportunities for students to begin studies in the face of immigration uncertainty in the United States and elsewhere.

In her book Regional Universities and International Joint Universities: Collaborative Models (2025), Jane Knight breaks these ventures into two approaches: a “collaborative TNE model” and an “independent TNE model.” As its name suggests, the collaborative TNE model involves programs such as joint degrees, collaborative online education, and campuses which “depend on joint governance, joint program development and delivery, and joint research projects,” says Knight, an adjunct professor at the Ontario Institute for Studies in Education at the University of Toronto who studies the field. By contrast, the independent model leans more on a “parent” university establishing franchise programs, branch campuses, and online and mixed education programs, “all of which offer the parent university credential,” she says.

While the independent model is still the predominant one, according to Knight, she notes that collaborative research and joint projects are growing, especially in science and technology disciplines. “This is in response to the fact that many of today’s global challenges cannot be addressed by one country alone,” she says. “While this brings many opportunities and benefits, new risks exist as well.”

Push and Pull

TNE’s growth is driven by both supply and demand considerations. “All the different pull and push factors are in favor of TNE,” Trifiró says.

Export Countries: The Policy Push

Across Australia, Canada, the UK, the United States and other large inbound nations, international student caps and broader immigration restrictions are prompting institutions to look abroad. In Australia, for example, the availability of duplicative TNE programs outside of the country can be grounds for rejecting a student visa application, according to Trifiró. In the UK, the number of international students studying in TNE settings outside of the country has outpaced the number of inbound international students since 2024-25, according to Universities UK International. And while the United States lacks a national international education policy, both the UK and Australia have positioned TNE as a key strategic pillar in theirs. “Governments are proactively encouraging education providers to bring their programs to students rather than bring them in,” Trifiró says.

Import Countries: Embracing Internationalization, Building Capacity

At the same time, a growing number of countries are looking to TNE to advance national priorities, including halting brain drain and addressing skills shortages. TNE is also seen as a means to internationalize and build capacity in domestic institutions. Countries with young populations and aspirations of boosting domestic enrollment are creating TNE-friendly policies, including the Gulf states, Nigeria, Pakistan, India, and Vietnam, says Ilieva. “Host countries are becoming more intentional and strategic in their engagement with TNE,” she says. “What is becoming a critical driver is that these jurisdictions have aspirations to retain talent.”

In a multipolar world, countries beyond the so-called “Big Fourteen” are also seeing the value of TNE to their own higher education systems, with institutions in Asia, Africa, and elsewhere launching TNE ventures in their own regions.

Student Mobility and Preferences

While the overall number of global higher education students has grown from 2 million to more than 7 million over the past two decades, the percentage who are internationally mobile has remained stubbornly in the 2-3 percent range, according to UNESCO.

The ongoing lack of student mobility presents TNE as an opportunity to more equitably expand access to higher education, according to Trifiró. The sudden halt in mobility during the pandemic also accelerated both the impetus—and the capacity—to provide quality education closer to students. 

As for the students who are mobile, growing numbers are seeking international options in their own regions of the world. “Students are staying closer to home when traveling abroad,” Lane says. “They still want to pursue foreign education but don’t want to travel that far.” 

Challenges and Opportunities

Despite strong headwinds, TNE ventures remain challenging to implement and maintain. According to C-BERT, 76 branch campuses worldwide have closed to date. “Lots of institutions decided where they wanted to go before they decided why they wanted to go somewhere,” Lane says.

Trifiró argues that a key issue is trust—or lack thereof—in three crucial areas: quality, purpose, and partnerships. Each area offers opportunities for institutions to improve their TNE offerings.

Quality

Too often, “TNE is still seen as a lower quality offer than the home campus provision,” Trifiró says. One challenge is that the quality assurance systems that guide higher education “are not really fit for purpose” in overseeing cross-border ventures, he adds.

Guidelines such as UNESCO’s Global Convention on the Recognition of Qualifications Concerning Higher Education operational guidelines and the UNESCO/Council of Europe Code of Good Practice in the Provision of Transnational Education stipulate that TNE should be of comparable quality to the home institution’s programming. They also stress the importance of transparency and an outcomes-based approach over credit hours or other rigid metrics.

Importing countries are now “paying much more attention [and] have new expectations of quality assurance,” Lane says. But accountability systems remain “very patchy,” Trifiró says, noting that programs overseen by two jurisdictions often must navigate overlapping, duplicative, and conflicting regulations. For exporting institutions, the high cost of in-country visits for TNE ventures has led their nations’ accountability systems to focus more closely on metrics—metrics such as post-graduation outcomes which may not be comparable or even obtainable in other countries, according to Trifiró. “I don't think any sending country has quality assurance oversight of TNE that could be regarded as comparable to its oversight of domestic provision,” he says.

“These are startup operations. Students who come to you are really taking a gamble. Being able to successfully graduate students [and] show they can get jobs is often a turning point for legitimacy in the local environment.” —Jason Lane

Trifiró argues that participating countries need to work more closely together, including undertaking joint review of TNE programs to reduce the regulatory burden. However, even in Europe with its highly integrated education system, only one-third of countries have endorsed such a joint approach, he says.

Beyond formal quality assurance, another key to building trust is focusing on the benefits to students in each country. One of the best ways to demonstrate student outcomes, Lane argues, is to successfully graduate them. “These are startup operations. Students who come to you are really taking a gamble,” Lane says. “Being able to successfully graduate students [and] show they can get jobs is often a turning point for legitimacy in the local environment.”

To that end, HWUM focuses on graduate employability, tracking metrics and strengthening experiential learning through career insight workshops, open houses, and partnerships with technology companies. “These initiatives reflect deliberate institutional decisions,” Al-Atabi says. “We believe that preparing students for employment . . .  means giving them opportunities to understand industry expectations, apply their learning, build professional relationships, and develop the confidence and adaptability needed in a changing workplace.”

Purpose

Many TNE ventures have been seen as “being primarily driven by financial considerations,” Trifiró says. The broader question is the extent to which TNE ventures reflect the needs of the countries they are hosted in. “Equality doesn’t equal quality,” Lane says, calling the move to localize programs in host countries a “major shift.”

“Campuses that have been successful long term maintain similarities with the home campus but localize degrees to the environments students are working in,” Lane says.

The “golden rule,” Trifiró argues, is that TNE ventures should be comparable to the programming of the home institution, holding students to similar outcomes and expected competencies and skills. The challenge comes in the context—the expectations of the learning environment, supports, and student life in different countries. 

“The strength of TNE lies in maintaining the academic quality and integrity of the home institution while ensuring that the education we deliver responds to the needs of the country in which we operate.” —Mushtak Al-Atabi

Context also reflects national needs. At HWUM, for example, institutional priorities reflect Malaysia’s National AI Action Plan and the country’s goal to develop higher-value industries, according to Al-Atabi. “For us, global standards and local relevance are complementary rather than competing priorities,” he says. “The strength of TNE lies in maintaining the academic quality and integrity of the home institution while ensuring that the education we deliver responds to the needs of the country in which we operate.”

Along with balancing home and local faculty and curriculum, context requires building local connections with employers and government. HWUM partners with local and global companies on mentorships, scholarships, and industry-integrated learning, Al-Atabi says.

And TNE ventures need to embrace internationalization themselves. At HWUM, a Go Global inter-campus transfer program provides students “opportunities to gain international exposure while maintaining continuity in their degree progression,” Al-Atabi says.

Partnerships

MOUs and other TNE partnership language is often framed around compliance, rather than shared values, common vision, or a long-term commitment to lasting benefit. “There are growing expectations that a partnership can demonstrate a commitment to advance each other’s strategic objectives,” Trifiró says, noting that partnerships “should be transformational rather than transactional. It must be a two-way relationship.”

Before considering partnerships, senior leadership needs to “assess internally whether it’s a strategy that the institution wants to pursue,” Lane says. That involves a realistic understanding of the resources needed to partner in targeted countries—and equally realistic expectations of demand. “Going in heavily on a global reputation doesn’t automatically translate into local recognition,” Lane says.

From there, building effective partnerships requires “embedding reciprocity from the start,” Trifiró argues. “That requires substantial and constructive exchange and dialogue between partners to ensure reciprocal understanding of expectations, red lines, and goals as they work towards a shared vision.”

“There are growing expectations that a partnership can demonstrate a commitment to advance each other’s strategic objectives.” —Fabrizio Trifiró

Al-Atabi agrees. “Universities must understand local priorities, maintain strong academic governance, invest in talent development, and demonstrate that their presence creates meaningful value for the host country,” he says.

Red lines are particularly critical. One involves “undesirable transfer of sensitive knowledge” in joint research projects, Knight cautions. Another involves what happens if revenue expectations aren’t met and the host institution or third-party investor pushes for changes in programming or admissions, Lane says. “Being clear about the firewalls is critical,” he adds. Because safeguarding students is key, partnerships should also detail how they will be allowed to complete their studies if the partnership comes to an unexpected end. 

Partnerships must be able to respond to changing regulatory frameworks and institutional priorities, according to Ilieva. “They have to evolve and change over time if they are to be sustained,” she says. This flexibility allows programs to grow in both size and scope, she adds: “The partnership becomes embedded in that local infrastructure where students and employers all interact. As a result, the remit of the partnership widens.”

Unlocking TNE’s Potential

Addressing these issues will allow the sector to “fully unlock the strategic and socially progressive potentials of TNE as a more sustainable, inclusive, and impactful mode of international education,” Trifiró argues. When done well, that impact can extend far beyond branch campuses and other ventures. For example, work done by students in a dual master’s degree program with the University of Liverpool and Bicol University in the Philippines led to dramatic reductions in pesticide use in Bicol province. “The local impact was huge,” Ilieva says. “It totally changed the farming community.”

To meet these aspirations, institutional leaders “carry a responsibility to contribute to the host country's human capital development, strengthen its education ecosystem, and demonstrate the value of the education being delivered,” Al-Atabi says. “Ultimately, the future of transnational education is not simply about where education is delivered. It is about how effectively universities connect global knowledge with local needs, prepare people for an uncertain future, and create opportunities that benefit both individuals and society.”  •

About International Educator

International Educator is NAFSA’s flagship publication and has been published continually since 1990. As a record of the association and the field of international education, IE includes articles on a variety of topics, trends, and issues facing NAFSA members and their work. 

From in-depth features to interviews with thought leaders and columns tailored to NAFSA’s knowledge communities, IE provides must-read context and analysis to those working around the globe to advance international education and exchange.

About NAFSA

NAFSA: Association of International Educators is the world's largest nonprofit association dedicated to international education and exchange. NAFSA serves the needs of more than 10,000 members and international educators worldwide at more than 3,500 institutions, in over 150 countries.

NAFSA membership provides you with unmatched access to best-in-class programs, critical updates, and resources to professionalize your practice. Members gain unrivaled opportunities to partner with experienced international education leaders.