Taking Stock of Partnerships
Partnerships are an increasingly important component of universities’ globalization strategies. Adding to their institution’s partnership portfolio is a top priority for many leaders, but the final goal isn’t quantity—it’s quality. Without an appropriate system to inventory, assess, and manage the agreements, a new or existing partnership isn’t going to deliver the impact that leaders seek.
As institutions look outside their campus to further their global education goals, the process of ramping up and managing a partnership portfolio is daunting and complex. What belongs in a portfolio inventory, and what tools are needed to manage it? How can leaders ensure that agreements tie into institutional strategy, and how often should they assess their portfolio? For offices just tackling these questions, the work ahead can seem endless.
“The complexity is a real challenge for people getting started,” says Kalpen Trivedi, senior vice provost and director of global affairs at the University of Massachusetts-Amherst. “It just doesn’t come all at once.” However, Trivedi and other leaders say that with planning, over time offices can develop a robust process for ensuring that partnerships are reaching their maximum potential and align with their institution’s goals.
Determine What’s Included
Understanding what should be included in a portfolio—and what should not—is a necessary first step. “How do you define international partnerships [at your institution]?” asks Tim Barnes, acting associate vice president for global engagement and executive director of international partnerships and research at the University of Kentucky. “If I was coming into a new position, that would be the first thing I would ask.”
The answer to the question will vary from institution to institution, but it likely will not include all global activities. “I think it is important to distinguish between an inventory of formal institutional agreements that underpin partnerships and the broader network of international academic collaborations,” says Alia Gilbrecht-Hindi, assistant director for university partnerships at the Institute for Global Engagement at the University of Houston.
“Our formal portfolio includes memoranda of understanding (MOUs), Reciprocal Educational Exchange Program (REEP) agreements, articulation agreements supporting transnational education, and other agreements establishing institutional commitments,” she notes. “But significant international engagement also takes place through faculty research collaborations, joint publications, visiting scholars, and virtual exchange initiatives that may not require formal agreements.”
“It is important to distinguish between an inventory of formal institutional agreements that underpin partnerships and the broader network of international academic collaborations.” —Alia Gilbrecht-Hindi,
However, just because an agreement is not part of an international office’s portfolio doesn’t mean it shouldn’t be on their radar. “We don't have research agreements in our stable, but we work very closely with the research office to ensure that we have access to information about research partnerships that have a global focus,” says Douglas Proctor, assistant vice president of global engagement and partnerships and the senior international officer at York University.
Develop a Framework for Inventory and Assessment
As important as knowing how to define a partnership is, it is equally important to have a deeper understanding of the existing inventory. But that doesn’t always give the full picture of a partnership portfolio, says Gilbrecht-Hindi.
“An inventory tells us which agreements exist, but it doesn't necessarily tell us what is happening through those relationships or where their greatest potential lies,” she notes. To develop a partnership framework that would guide the process, Gilbrecht-Hindi spent time examining the university’s agreements and collaborating with faculty and staff engaged with them. “We wanted to understand not only what activity was working, but where there was potential for growth and what institutional support could help partnerships succeed,” she says.
As new agreements are considered for the portfolio, it’s important to ensure that they are tied to the university’s strategy and mission. “I would say my first piece of advice for professionals in this field is to consider things from their institutional lens,” says Jennifer Hilton Ortiz, senior director for international initiatives at the University of Texas-Dallas (UTD). “What are the objectives? What are the priorities? What are the most important aspects that partnerships could support?”
“Make sure you have a really clear framework around the decision-making that you're going to deploy. Otherwise, you are just beholden to a very complex set of internal stakeholders who all feel as though if you say no to them, that you're misguided.” —Douglas Proctor
Inevitably, answering those questions involves stakeholders across campus. For Ortiz, that includes a campus-wide International Education Development Committee that meets monthly to review and approve new partnerships. The committee’s members include representatives from the registrar's office, admissions office, travel and safety office, and deans’ offices, as well as student leadership.
Having an agreed-upon framework for considering partnerships helps facilitate the review and approval process for potential new partnerships. Leaders recommend posting those guidelines online so that they are readily available to faculty and other stakeholders. For example, UTD has a best practices guide outlining types of agreements, the timeline involved in developing and reviewing them, and the steps need to ensure their success.
Such a guide makes it easier to determine what constitutes a partnership and when to say no to a proposal. “Make sure you have a really clear framework around the decision-making that you're going to deploy,” says Proctor. “Otherwise, you are just beholden to a very complex set of internal stakeholders who all feel as though if you say no to them, that you're misguided.”
Conduct Regular Reviews
Leaders recommend regular reviews of partnership agreements to ensure that they are meeting their goals. “I recommend treating assessment as an ongoing process rather than a one-time exercise,” Gilbrecht-Hindi advises. “An initial comprehensive review establishes a baseline, while brief annual check-ins and more substantive reviews at agreement renewal help keep information current.”
Different partnerships will have different measures of success, she notes. The goal is not to evaluate every partnership with the same intensity, but to use proportionate assessment methods that consider institutional priorities, meaningful outcomes, and the capacity of faculty, departments, and institutions to sustain the relationship.
Even for more casual agreements, such as MOUs, it’s important to measure outcomes. “I always push for an MOU to have some tangible [aspects],” says Proctor. “Rather than having a generic MOU that says we're just going to be friendly and do things together, [including tangible activities] actually nominates some things that you're going to do together.”
“The biggest mistake people make is thinking that these partnerships are just paper-pushing activities and underestimate the investment that they take to ensure they are producing a return that both parties find meaningful.” —Jennifer Hilton Ortiz
The assessments can go beyond the deliverables in the agreement. “We in the United States at least can tend to be very outcome-driven,” says Ortiz. “That’s not necessarily the case in other parts of the world. I think the biggest mistake people make is thinking that these partnerships are just paper-pushing activities and underestimate the investment that they take to ensure they are producing a return that both parties find meaningful.”
Some agreements don’t fulfill their goals. “Faculty relationships are often a partnership's greatest strength,” Gilbrecht-Hindi notes. “However, attachment to a partnership is not necessarily the same as active commitment or institutional capacity to sustain it.” While there are opportunities to repair or revitalize a flagging partnership, sometimes an agreement needs to be phased out, whether resources, including staffing, aren’t available, or the agreement doesn’t align with the institution’s goals anymore. Other partnerships may have simply run their course.
Choose a Management Tool
While many global partnership offices rely on customer management relationship systems (CRMs), offices just starting the process of inventorying and analyzing their partnerships can rely on simpler tools.
“Everybody starts with Excel,” says Proctor. “You have to start somewhere.” Still, Proctor cautions, spreadsheets “can only be an interim solution because I don’t think you can manage such a complex function out of a spreadsheet.”
Gilbrecht-Hindi notes that there are plenty of other tools available to get the process started without a huge investment. “While specialized platforms can streamline agreement management and reporting, institutions without access to them can still build effective processes using existing campus databases or shared spreadsheets, standardized records, regular surveys, and accessible data visualization tools such as Excel or Power BI dashboards to monitor partnership activity and identify trends,” she says.
“Data is coming to reign supreme for academic partnerships.” —Tim Barnes
However, a more sophisticated system would be able to provide the most value for global partnership offices in the long run. “My first pieces of advice to any institution looking to improve their partnership management is to invest in a CRM,” says Ortiz. “There are many out there and they all have their pros and cons.”
Other sources of data can supplement the CRM. “We pull data and reports from different systems, not just the CRM,” says Trivedi. He cites mobility data, data from the travel system, and publication and grant data as other resources that help paint a fuller picture of how a partnership is working and where future partnerships might make sense.
“Data is coming to reign supreme for academic partnerships,” Barnes argues. “One data point I use a lot is international co-authorships. This happens all the time, often with very little knowledge on the part of the international office.” However, he says, that data can reveal a lot about the value of a partnership or where a partnership would benefit the university.
“If you have a colleague in the medical school who has been citing the same population in Hong Kong for 25 years and is publishing high-impact papers, that suggests a partnership you may want to look at,” says Barnes. “You can use that kind of data to cast your net widely to see activity that is not covered in your database.”
Get Started
That level of data mining may be years away for offices just starting to build the process to inventory and manage their partnership portfolio. In the meantime, partnership offices shouldn’t be put off by the work ahead.
What matters most is the habit of treating partnerships as relationships that need sustained attention, rather than as signatures on paper. Leaders who do so are better positioned to deepen the partnerships that are working and recognize new opportunities that will help their portfolio grow in value—not just in size.
“Don’t be phased by the complexity of it,” says Trivedi. “It’s always going to seem like an insurmountable task, no matter when you do it. You just have to start.” •
NAFSA Resources
About International Educator
International Educator is NAFSA’s flagship publication and has been published continually since 1990. As a record of the association and the field of international education, IE includes articles on a variety of topics, trends, and issues facing NAFSA members and their work.
From in-depth features to interviews with thought leaders and columns tailored to NAFSA’s knowledge communities, IE provides must-read context and analysis to those working around the globe to advance international education and exchange.
About NAFSA
NAFSA: Association of International Educators is the world's largest nonprofit association dedicated to international education and exchange. NAFSA serves the needs of more than 10,000 members and international educators worldwide at more than 3,500 institutions, in over 150 countries.
NAFSA membership provides you with unmatched access to best-in-class programs, critical updates, and resources to professionalize your practice. Members gain unrivaled opportunities to partner with experienced international education leaders.